Why Does the Brain Make Mistakes When It Is Uncertain?

Scientists identify a neuronal mechanism of interference

Does Brain Make Mistakes? When we do not know exactly what is happening, the brain must make decisions using incomplete information. New research shows that uncertainty can cause irrelevant information to interfere with neural representations, increasing the likelihood of perceptual errors and mistaken decisions.

POR QUE O CEREBRO ERRA QUANDO NÃO TEM CERTEZA mecanismo neuronal da interferencia

Imagine that you are performing a simple task, but the rules change without warning.

What mattered a few seconds ago may no longer be relevant. At the same time, information that previously had to be ignored may become necessary.

The brain must quickly determine which information deserves attention.

Uma pesquisa publicada em September 10, 2026, in the journal Nature Neuroscience found evidence of a neural mechanism that may explain why this situation becomes more difficult: when there is uncertainty about a task, irrelevant information can interfere within neural networks.

🧠 When we do not know what to look for

Our brain is constantly trying to determine what matters and what can be ignored.

When certainty is high, this selection is relatively straightforward.

If we know that we need to focus on an object’s location, for example, features such as its frequency or other properties can be disregarded.

But what happens when we are unsure which feature will be relevant?

This is precisely when the brain appears to become more vulnerable to interference.

🔬 An experiment combining the brain, behavior, and artificial intelligence

To investigate this phenomenon, the researchers combined three different approaches:

🐒 Electrophysiology in monkeys — to directly record neuronal activity during the tasks.

👁️ Psychophysics in humans — to measure how uncertainty affected perception and decision-making.

🤖 Artificial neural networks — to compare a system trained to produce correct responses with another trained to reproduce the behavior observed in participants.

This combination allowed the researchers not only to observe when errors occurred, but also to investigate why they occurred.

🎯 Uncertainty increased errors

Tanto os humanos quanto os macacos apresentaram pior desempenho when havia incerteza sobre qual tarefa deveriam executar.

Responses also became slower.

The greater the uncertainty, the greater the behavioral cost.

But there was an important difference.

An artificial neural network trained specifically to produce correct responses did not show the same performance cost.

This provided the researchers with a clue.

Perhaps the problem was not simply the difficulty of the task.

It may instead lie in the way the human and animal brain simultaneously represents competing information.

⚡ The problem may be interference

Os pesquisadores propuseram a chamada feature interference hypothesis (feature interference).

When a task is uncertain, a feature that should be ignored may continue to be strongly represented by the brain.

This irrelevant information then competes with the information actually needed to make a decision.

It is as if different signals were trying to occupy the same space.

The problem is not necessarily a lack of information.

It may be too much information competing at once.

🧠 What happened inside the neurons?

Os registros realizados no primary visual cortex (V1) in monkeys provided physiological evidence for this hypothesis.

Under conditions of greater uncertainty, features considered irrelevant remained more strongly represented in neuronal activity.

Ao mesmo tempo, as representações de diferentes características ficavam mais intertwined.

This less distinct organization may make it harder for the brain to select the correct information.

In other words:

more uncertainty → more interference → more overlapping representations → a higher likelihood of error.

🔄 The brain may “mix” information

Imagine two pieces of information represented by two different patterns of neuronal activity.

When these patterns are clearly separated, the brain can distinguish them relatively easily.

But when these representations begin to overlap, it becomes harder to distinguish one from the other.

This was exactly the kind of change the researchers observed.

Uncertainty increased the representation of irrelevant features and reduced the separation between different neural representations.

This offers a possible explanation for something we all experience:

when não sabemos exatamente o que devemos procurar, podemos acabar prestando atenção justamente naquilo que não importa.

🤖 How artificial intelligence helped explain the phenomenon

Artificial neural networks played a particularly interesting role in the study.

The researchers trained one network to produce correct responses and another to reproduce the behavior observed in monkeys.

The second network showed a similar pattern of interference.

A primeira, treinada para produzir correct responses, não apresentou o mesmo custo comportamental.

This comparison made it possible to formulate a mechanistic hypothesis:

o comportamento menos preciso pode surgir when representações neurais de diferentes características deixam de permanecer suficientemente separadas.

Artificial intelligence was therefore used not merely as a prediction tool.

It helped the researchers test possible explanations for how the brain works.

🧩 This helps explain our cognitive limitations

The human brain can perform an impressive range of tasks.

But this capacity is not unlimited.

We must select information, switch between tasks, keep goals in memory, and ignore irrelevant stimuli.

The new study suggests that some of these limitations may arise from a relatively simple principle:

different neural representations can interfere with one another.

This means that some cognitive difficulties may not be caused simply by a lack of attention.

They may result from the architecture of neural networks that must represent multiple pieces of information simultaneously.

⚠️ This does not mean that uncertainty always causes errors

The findings should be interpreted carefully.

Uncertainty does not mean that the brain will necessarily make an error.

Nosso sistema nervoso possui mecanismos sofisticados para lidar com ambientes imprevisíveis e tomar decisões mesmo when as informações são incompletas.

O estudo identifica a mechanism that may contribute to the behavioral cost of uncertainty, especialmente when diferentes características precisam ser processadas e selecionadas.

In addition, the experiments combined data from humans, monkeys, and computational models. This helps clarify the mechanism, but it does not mean that every observed aspect is identical across species.

🌎 A finding with implications beyond the laboratory

The research may help us better understand situations in which we must make decisions quickly while information is changing.

Task switching, unpredictable environments, excessive stimulation, and the need to select relevant information are common in everyday life and professional settings.

The finding does not provide a single explanation for all human errors.

But it offers a new way to think about them:

sometimes, the brain does not make mistakes because it received too little information.

It may make mistakes because too much information is competing within the same network.

🔬 When uncertainty changes how the brain processes information

The study’s key contribution is its connection between three different levels:

behavior → neuronal activity → computational mechanism.

Os resultados sugerem que a incerteza pode aumentar a representação de informações irrelevantes e fazer com que diferentes representações neurais se tornem mais intertwined.

This may turn a simple question about “what should I look for?” into a problem of neural processing.

In the brain, knowing what to ignore can be just as important as knowing what to notice.


Scientific source: Xue, C. et al. Feature interference underlies a neuronal basis for the behavioral cost of task uncertainty. Nature Neuroscience, published on September 10, 2026. DOI: 10.1038/s41593-026-02430-w.

IAN editorial note: the findings described combine experiments in humans and monkeys with artificial neural network modeling. The research identifies a possible interference mechanism associated with uncertainty, but should not be interpreted as a complete explanation for all human errors or decisions.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top